WHAT A GREAT WEEKEND!!

The Super League semi-finals provided us with two games of contrasting performances and quality.

On Thursday night Wigan Warriors qualified for their third successive Grand Final under Shaun Wane and really didn’t have to break sweat against a Huddersfield Giants side that, once again, totally bottled it on the big occasion.

I said to my eldest son before kick-off that I hoped the Giants would finally do themselves justice in the play-off’s and make their first Grand Final – the last thing I wanted to see was smug Wiganer’s celebrating another Grand Final appearance.

Unfortunately, within the first 20 minutes I knew there was no chance of the Giants winning the game – they simply lacked the belief in their undoubted ability and did not play anywhere near the standard they had the previous week against Leeds Rhinos.

I don’t believe this rubbish that Ryan Hall’s last second try had knocked all of the fight out of the Giants – they went toe to toe with the best British club side of the last 10 years last week and should have beaten them and this week they simply did not have the cahounas to push on and win at a ground that they are regular victors at – albeit it was their third defeat this season at the DW Stadium.

Frustrated coach - Paul Anderson.

I feel for the Giants coach Paul Anderson. That performance was purely down to his players and he must be racking his brains to work out how he can get his team to perform when it really matters and when there is more than just two competition points on the line.

The standard of the Giants performance was so poor that the Warriors simply cantered to a 32-8 win and, along with a poor crowd of just over 10,000, it was a lacklustre start to what promised to be a fantastic weekend of Rugby League.

Thank God for Headingley on a Friday night under the floodlights. 

There is no finer sight in British Rugby League than a heaving and pulsating Headingley Stadium with the floodlights on and a big game to be played at this magnificent rugby league ground.

The Rhinos and St. Helens served up a truly magnificent game that could have been won by either side in the last few minutes in front of over 17,000 passionate and excited fans and would have graced the Grand Final itself.

Saints can really count themselves unlucky not to have won this game.

They played some great rugby and were led superbly by Jon Wilkin and I am still not sure that the try that edged Leeds in front by Ryan Hall was actually a try.

Ryan Hall looks on in hope!!

There have been too many instances this season were the rules that govern how a try should be scored i.e. full control and downward pressure, have been pushed to their limits and tries have been given when a little finger only has been present – it’s been totally ridiculous at times – and I stick with my first thought on Friday night that Hall did not have full control of the ball and was unable to put downward pressure on the ball with his wrist.

If that try was not given, Saints would have maintained their 13-8 lead and Luke Walsh would not have had to push for a panic play that went wrong and enabled Kallum Watkins to extend the Rhinos lead and take them clear of the Saints.

However, it seemed that nothing was going to keep the Leed’s legends Jamie Peacock and Kevin Sinfield from making their final swansong in the Grand Final next week that’s how it should be – they have been great servant’s of both the Rhinos and the game of rugby league and that Sinfield 40/20 at a vital moment of the second half proved crucial and shows that whoever replaces him has massive boots to fill.

Saints coach Kieron Cunningham was magnanimous in defeat and spoke wonderfully at the final whistle and maybe Bradford Bulls coach James Lowes can take some lessons from his former hooking foe.

Clubs have known for a year that the final Super League spot for 2016 would come down to a direct one off match between the teams that finished 4^th and 5^th after the completion of the middle 8’s qualifying games.

At a minimum teams like Wakefield, Bradford and Leigh would have wanted to take part in this game.

Obviously they would have preferred to finish in the top 3 of the middle 8’s and qualify for next year’s Super League automatically, but it was always likely that two of the aforementioned three teams would play for the final place.

James Lowes

With that in mind I cannot agree with James Lowes’ outburst immediately after the game live on Sky.

He said that this type of match should not be allowed and that the pressure was too great for the players and the game was playing with their livelihoods and that losing this game may mean players losing their jobs or going part-time.

All due respect to Lowes but I think both clubs knew exactly what they were getting themselves into.

This was not just an overnight introduction, they knew this was a possibility a year ago and I am sure the clubs would have had a Plan A (Super League) and Plan B (Championship) drawn up – ‘Plan for the Worst, Hope for the Best’.

If the Bulls have planned with the above ethos in mind then they should not be in a position where they have to start slashing jobs on Monday morning. I would put money on the Bulls remaining full time next year.

Lowes also kicked off about two ‘controversial’ refereeing decisions – both of which I think Richard Silverwood and his team got right – and as much as he looks for excuses elsewhere he may want to look closer to home and look at his own coaching ability.

The game itself was tense and exciting and of a decent quality in front of a season high crowd of over 7,000 at Belle Vue. Young forward Chris Annakin had an outstanding game for the Wildcats as did Jacob Miller and Adrian Purtell once again stood out for the Bulls – what about that pass behind his back for Danny Williams’ try!!!

Huge credit has to go to Head Coach Brian Smith, Chairman Michael Carter and the Wildcats players for keeping things together after a tough couple of weeks which saw them lose, arguably, their two best players Kevin Locke and Tim Smith after a sojourn to Hull in a club car went horribly wrong.

The Wildcats still have a lot of work to do to avoid any chance of being in a similar position next year and that needs to start with persuading Brian Smith to stay in charge – the Super League will be greater with him involved and the Wildcats will have a greater opportunity of avoiding the nerve shredding Million Pound Game in 2016.

The weekend got even better on Sunday as the North Queensland Cowboys and Brisbane Broncos fought out the first all Queensland Grand Final in the heart of Sydney.

The game had everything – great tries, great defence, a wonderful one handed pass to set up a LAST SECOND equalising try, a winning conversion attempt that hit the post, a golden point drop goal to give North Queensland their first ever Premiership and an all-round wonderful performance from Jonathan Thurston that will live long in the memory – never before has one player been so instrumental in dragging his team to a Premiership.

Put simply, without JT the Cowboys would be nowhere near a Grand Final. They have some quality players, but he is the glue that sticks everything together.

A wonderful attacking first half saw four tries scored, two from each side, and Brisbane led their junior neighbours 14-12.

The second half was full of some desperate and outstanding defence and despite the best efforts of the Cowboys, Kane Linnett lost the ball with the try line at his mercy and Lachlan Coote had a try ruled out for a double movement, the half remained tryless until the very last second of the game.

Ben Hunt gave away a needless penalty for a dangerous tackle on Linnett and the Cowboys, trailing 16-12 after Corey Parker kicked an earlier penalty for the only score of the second half, launched one final do or die attack.

Thurston was involved, as he was with everything the Cowboys did, but it was his half back partner Michael Morgan who provided the moment of magic.

He took Thurston’s speculative pass and ran to his right on an arc that drew in three panicing Broncos defenders – Morgan remained calm, got his right arm free and slipped out a wonderful one handed pass to wingman Kyle Feldt.

Feldt was cool enough to plant the ball down one handed just as the clock hit 80 minutes bang on – it was theatre and drama of the highest order and there was still an encore to come.

Kyle Feldt scores THAT try.

Thurston is one of the world’s top goal kickers as well and his low swinging attempt with his right foot from the touchline looked like it was going to swing in and win the Premiership for the Cowboys but it hit the right hand upright instead and bounced out. Thurston bellowed out his frustration and Golden Point extra time beckoned with the scores tied at 16-16.

You have to feel for Broncos half back Ben Hunt, not only did he give away the penalty that gave the Cowboys the position to launch their final attack of the match, but he also knocked on the kick off that gave Thurston the opportunity to write his name into the history books and to put his name right there at the top of the list for the honour of being the next Immortal.

JT drops the winning goal.

Hunt dropped the ball just in front of his own line and from the resulting set Thurston got his hands on the ball 25 yards out and clipped over the winning Golden Point drop goal to give the Cowboys their first ever Premiership win – cue hysteria for the Cowboys and heartache for the Broncos.

Cue hysteria for the Cowboys.

Thurston was awarded the Clive Churchill Medal as man of the match to add to his fourth Dally M player of the year award that he won earlier in the week – I think there can be no doubt about who is the greatest rugby league player on the planet at the moment.

The NRL Grand Final rounded off a superb weekend of rugby league which showed that our game isn’t great all of the time but when it is at it’s best there is no other spectacle like it.

Highlights of the Grand Final can be seen here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8CUWpLIax44

It also showed that it doesn’t have to be the so called big clubs that run out winners all of the time and Super League really does need a smaller club to drag itself up by the boot straps and take out a Grand Final.

Only four clubs, Bradford Bulls, Wigan Warriors, St. Helens and Leeds Rhinos have won the Super League Grand Final since it’s inaugural year in 1998 and only 6 clubs have made the Final – Hull FC and Warrington Wolves being the unwanted interlopers. This needs to change and soon.

Let’s hope that the Theatre of Dreams, Old Trafford, is just that next Saturday night as Leeds Rhinos and Wigan Warriors battle for the 2015 Super League title and let’s hope that 2016 sees a new kid enter the block and make a real challenge for title.

 

MY ENGLAND SQUAD FOR THE NEW ZEALAND TEST SERIES

As the 2015 Super League season ratchets up to a, hopefully, spectacular conclusion with two mouth-watering semi-finals this weekend followed by the Grand Final next Saturday, my thoughts have turned to the up-coming England v. New Zealand Three Match Test Series that will take part across consecutive weekends in November.

The Kiwi’s are now the number one world ranked Test nation following three consecutive wins over Australia and are the current Four Nations champions.

However, they have been hit with a raft of withdrawals of major players due to injury headed by Golden Boot winner Shaun Johnson and including all-time leading try scorer Manu Vatuvei, experienced hooker / half back Thomas Leuluai and star prop forward Jared Warea-Haergreaves.

Johnson’s half back partner Kieran Foran has joined that list this week and will miss the tour because of an elbow ligament injury.

Even with these great players missing, I still expect it to be a hugely competitive Test Series as the Kiwi’s strength in depth is greater than it has ever been and competitors like Isaac Luke, Simon Mannering, Shaun Kenny-Dowall and Simon Mannering will not want to relinquish their hard earned no.1 status too easily.

Therefore, England will have to be at their best to win this series and take out the Baskerville Shield.

Head Coach Steve McNamara will be selecting a squad of 23 players and is already without the services of centre Dan Sarginson, who had a brilliant Four Nations tournament last year, and prop forward George Burgess – both of whom would have been highly likely to be in the starting 13.

McNamara still has a lot of quality players to select from and I found it difficult to come up with the right squad variation to get the players in place that will be needed to win this series.

The New Zealanders will be big in the forwards and our pack will need to more than match them and we will also need to be highly skilled in the backs.

Here is my squad for the Test Series – followed by my first choice 17 to start the series:

FULL BACKS

We are blessed to have two high quality full backs and it is easy to select SAM TOMKINS and ZAK HARDAKER. Tomkins has had an injury hit 2015 but is still a high quality player whilst Hardaker has been in the form of his life. To add to the options of the squad Tomkins can also play in the halves and Hardaker in the three quarters.  I think England need to have both of these players in their starting 13 to win this series.

WINGERS
We have top quality wingers in abundance. RYAN HALL has not had the greatest year of his career but he is a shoe in on the left wing spot. His experience and ability to score tries from nothing is a must have and I cannot see an England side without him in it. JERMAINE MCGILIVARY is another player in the form of his life and is Super League’s leading try scorer. He should have done enough to earn a place in the squad and will also be joined by JOE BURGESS. Burgess overcame a shaky start to the season to once again become a regular try scorer for the Warriors and he and McGilivary earned selection for the Super League Dream Team. My main query here was how many wingers do you pick in a 23 man squad for a three match series? I have gone with just the three mentioned and that means big name players like Tom Briscoe and Josh Charnley miss out.

CENTRES

As much as Hall is a shoe in on the wing, his Leeds Rhinos team mate KALLUM WATKINS is also certain to fill one of the centre spots. I think the injured Dan Sarginson would definitely have been selected alongside Castleford Tigers captain MICHAEL SHENTON. As with the wingers I have selected just three centres and my third selection is St. Helen’s three-quarter JORDAN TURNER. Turner is big and strong and has pace and an eye for the try line. Brisbane Broncos Grand Finalist Jack Reed has had a good season in the NRL but I am more than happy with the above selections.

STAND OFF

Incumbent GARETH WIDDOP has had an excellent season for St. George Illawarra Dragons and will keep his place as long as he is injury free. I have also selected Warrington Wolves STEFAN RATCHFORD as he can also cover full back, centre and loose forward positions. He had a strong season in a struggling Wolves outfit. Young Wigan half back George Williams was not far away from this squad but, like his coach Shaun Wane, I think it is a little too early for him and he is better off having an off season with a full pre-season. Kevin Brown can also consider himself to be incredibly unlucky.

SCRUM HALF

I am torn here between the organisational ability of Matty Smith and the more dynamic play of Castleford Tigers LUKE GALE – the winner of the Rugby League Express Albert Goldthorpe Medal. Do we need two scrum halves in a squad of just 23 when we went into last year’s Four Nations tournament with just one?? It’s a tough one - but to give us an extra forward in the squad I have selected Gale only as I believe he will offer the team more in attack and is a better player than Smith.

PROPS

The big boys up front will need to be at full tilt and George Burgess is a big loss. However, we have strength in the front row like no other position. JAMES GRAHAM, CHRIS HILL AND TOM BURGESS  are certain selections and I would definitely select St. Helen’s prop ALEX WALMSLEY to come from the bench and provide impact. The fifth prop is likely to be the Dragons MIKE COOPER who has had another strong year in the NRL. Hull FC prop Liam Watts will just miss out.

HOOKER

The hooking position is another area where we have a number of options. JAMES ROBY missed last season’s Four Nations through injury but is a certainty for this squad. Last year’s Man of Steel Daryl Clark has had a poor first season at Warrington Wolves and I would not select him for the squad. Instead I would select JOSH HODGSON as the back-up hooker. His performances in the NRL for the Canberra Raiders have drawn great praise in Australia and I believe he deserves to keep hold of his squad place. Wigan’s Michael McIlorum will also be in contention but in my mind he give’s away too many penalties and Isaac Luke would seriously try to wind him up. Plus Roby and Hodgson are all round better players.

SECOND ROW

ELLIOTT WHITEHEAD was severely underused in last year’s Four Nations competition and has had another very good year for Catalans Dragons and fully deserves to retain his place in the squad. LIAM FARRELL has again been a model of consistency for Wigan Warriors and I think 2 young guns also deserve to be selected. Warrington’s BEN CURRIE has had a great year. He is a class act with strength, power and pace and can also play centre if needed to as can Wigan Warrior’s JOHN BATEMAN. Bateman has been described as freak by Shaun Wane. He is the ultimate competitor and does not give an inch. I am hoping McNamara does not make the same mistake as last year and pick Joel Tomkins on reputation only – he does not deserve a place. The experience of Ben Westwood makes him a contender but I think his time as an international has come to an end.

LOOSE FORWARD

SEAN O’LOUGHLIN is the team captain and a certain starter. After missing 3 months early in the season O’Loughlin has played consistently to his usual high standard. He needs to be on top form to provide the leadership, aggression and skill that England will need to win this series.

My full squad is as follows:

Sam Tomkins, Zak Hardaker, Ryan Hall, Jermain McGilivary, Joe Burgess, Kallum Watkins, Michael Shenton, Jordan Turner, Gareth Widdop, Stefan Rathford, Luke Gale, James Graham, Chris Hill, Tom Burgess, Alex Walmsley, Mike Cooper, James Roby, Josh Hodgson, Elliott Whitehead, Liam Farrell, Ben Currie, John Bateman, Sean O’Loughlin.

My 17 for the First Test would be:

FULL BACK:                         SAM TOMKINS

WINGERS:                           RYAN HALL and JERMAINE MCGILIVARY

CENTRES:                            KALLUM WATKINS and ZAK HARDAKER

STAND OFF:                        GARETH WIDDOP

SCRUM HALF:                     LUKE GALE

PROPS:                                 JAMES GRAHAM and CHRIS HILL

HOOKER:                             JAMES ROBY

SECOND ROWS:                 ELLIOTT WHITEHEAD and LIAM FARRELL

LOOSE FORWARD:            SEAN O’LOUGHLIN (captain)

SUBSTITUTES:                    ALEX WALMSLEY, TOM BURGESS, JOSH HODGSON, BEN CURRIE

I have dropped 6 players from the 2014 Four Nations squad – Josh Charnley, Daryl Clark, Brett Ferres, Joel Tomkins, Matt Smith and Joe Westerman and 2 players are out injured - Dan Sarginson and George Burgess.

7 new players come into the squad - Jermaine McGillivary, Jordan Turner, Luke Gale, Alex Walmsley, James Roby, John Bateman and Ben Currie.

But what do I know – I just find it fun to have a look at the squad and open a debate.

Feel free to criticise or make your own selections.

COME ON ENGLAND!!!!!!

You can follow me on Twitter @sharpster69

SIX TO GO – TWITTER, GALE STORMS AND RETIREMENTS

Welcome to the latest edition of Six to Go, looking at some of the things that have caught my eye over the past week or so.

Eddie and Stevo in the early days.

#askskyrl – the gift that keeps on giving

One of the great things about Twitter is that it gives you the ability to make contact with famous people and let you know how much you admire them or, if you are that way inclined, how much of a moron you consider them to be but you can also have fantastic debates about a whole range of subjects with other fans, journalists and sometimes even players and some of the banter that gets thrown about at times is priceless.

It was with some amazement and a certain amount of joy that I saw that Sky had decided to open up communication between it’s viewers and the venerable and much maligned Eddie and Stevo and their little protégé Phil Clarke. The rest of the team including Brian Carney, Barrie McDermott and Jon Wells were also included but you just knew that the cream of the crop questions would all be aimed at Eddie and Stevo in particular with Clarkey getting a mouthful as well.

What amazed me even more was this wasn’t just a one off – they’ve done it for the last couple of weeks as well – obviously some of the fans have actually been asking serious questions rather than extracting the Michael but some of the questions / comments that I have seen have been hilarious and have left me in tears.

Below is a selection of my favourites – not all of them are politically correct and NONE of them are from me.

‘’Did Sam Tomkins lose his virginity to Eddie and Stevo?’’

‘’Has Phil Clarke ever shown you his Sam Tomkins tattoo?’’

‘’8x6=??’’

‘’Is it true you are tighter than cramp?’’

‘’Who is prettier? Phil Clarke or Jon Wilkin?’’

‘’You guys don’t half talk crap.’’

‘’My daughter is 3years old and talks more sense about the game.’’

‘’Who would win a fight? Barrie or Terry?’’

‘’Do you actually understand the rules or do you like to disagree with everyone for fun?’’

‘’Why don’t you stop waffling on about complete and utter bollocks during the game?’’

‘’When will Rod Studd & Jon Wells take over as commentators? They are knowledgeable, entertaining and don’t talk shit.’’

And these are some of the one’s that I dared to print.

James Webster

Webbo’s Boy’s.

It’s good to see that James Webster is back in rugby league and I think that he is an outstanding appointment as the first Head Coach of the controversial joint City of Hull Academy set up.

Webster is well respected in the city through his time as a player at Hull Kingston Rovers, where he was instrumental in getting the Robins into Super League, and as assistant coach at Hull FC under Richard Agar.

Although Webster’s time as Head Coach of Wakefield Trinity Wildcats ended prematurely after a horrendous run of injury’s led to 11 successive Super League defeats and a Challenge Cup defeat to Leigh Centurions, I really believe that he has proved that he is an outstanding coach and the experience he has gained as a player in Australia and the UK can only benefit the young players that he will be charged with looking after in the City of Hull Academy.

Webster actually started his coaching career at Hull KR when he was the interim player-coach between the sacking of Harvey Howard and the appointment of Justin Morgan way back in 2005 – he led the team to 9 straight wins including a National Rail Cup Final win over Castleford Tigers and galvanised the club in a way that has not been forgotten.

His performances on the field of play are also well remembered in East Hull and he is still held in very high regard for the service he gave to Hull KR (despite signing for and coaching Hull FC!!) in both the Championship (or National League as it was then) and Super League even though a shoulder injury early in the 2008 season forced his early release from the club.

Apparently 2 Super League players on the verge of retirement and 2 coaches with Super League experience were also interviewed but, personally, I don’t think the new Academy could be in much better hands.

Moz and THAT red card.

Moz calls time.

Without a shadow of a doubt Adrian Morley has been one of the stand out British rugby league players of the last 20 years and there can be no doubting his impact and standing in the game of rugby league not just in the UK but also in Australia.

What a great career he has had.

It was a gangly youth that he made his debut alongside his boyhood hero Ellery Hanley for Leeds back in pre-Super League 1995. He went on to play in the inaugural Grand Final in 1998, which the Rhinos lost 10-4 to Wigan Warriors, before winning the Challenge Cup the following year as the Rhinos defeated London Broncos 52-16.

Morley became a hulking behemoth that terrorised Australians and New Zealanders in a record breaking international career that included a total of 51 caps (30 for GB and 21 for England).

He left Leeds Rhinos in 2000 and enjoyed a very successful six year stint in the NRL with Sydney Roosters, where he played in three consecutive Grand Finals, defeating New Zealand Warriors in 2002.

The Roosters went on to win the World Club Championship in 2003 with a 38-0 rout of Super League champions St. Helens, Moz scoring one of the five Roosters tries. The Roosters enjoyed great success over the next couple of years making the Grand Final in each year before losing to Penrith Panthers in 2003 and Canterbury Bulldogs in 2004.

Moz returned to the UK a more mature player in 2007 and helped inspire Warrington Wolves to three Challenge Cup wins in 2009, 2010 and 2012 and two losing Grand Final appearances in 2012 and 2013.

During his time at the Roosters, Morley even manged to sneak in a cameo 6 game stint with Bradford Bulls in 2005 that included a Grand Final winning appearance against his old team Leeds Rhinos. In doing so he became the first Englishman to win the British and Australian Grand Finals alongside the Challenge cup.

Morley chose to end his career at his hometown club Salford Red Devils and was part of Marwan Koukash’s ‘Devilution’ that has so far failed to reap the rewards that were intended.

He will be remembered as something of a hot head in his early years but he developed into a hard running, hard tackling no-nonsense prop forward who was admired and liked greatly by both his team mates and opponents.

Obviously, his most infamous moment was being sent off after just 12 seconds of the First Test of the 2003 Ashes series for a high shot on Robbie Kearns directly from the kick off. No player has ever been sent off quicker in a rugby league international.

Moz has always been a modest and honest man and has called time on his career at the right time I think. There is nothing worse than a star player going on too long.

He will, quite rightly, be recalled as a genuine great of the modern day game and his continued involvement at some level needs to be guaranteed – rugby league does not make enough use of our ex players.

Here are some highlights of the big man's career: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOdKzxAxhU0

Gale for England?

Gale Storms it for the Tigers

Luke Gale has proved himself to be the best scrum half in England with his consistently high quality performances in a Castleford Tigers squad that has taken no notice of many people’s pre-season predictions (mine included) that they would struggle to match their performances of 2014.

Winning the Rugby League Express Albert Goldthorpe medal shows that Gale has regularly put in performances that have greatly influenced his teams performances and won them games.

He has been an outstanding signing made by an outstanding coach in Daryl Powell.

Gale had a slow start to the season, as did Cas, as he struggled to settle in after his move from the relegated Bradford Bulls but since getting used to his team mates and feeling comfortable in his role as the team leader he has led the Tigers around the park with huge confidence and no little skill.

Gale is a strong organiser but is also dangerous when running at the line and either breaking defensive lines or slipping out a pass for a team mate to charge onto.

A record of 11 tries (bettered only by Albert Kelly and Danny McGuire in the scrum half stakes) and 27 try assists (second to Danny Brough) is an excellent return and his man of the match performance against Leeds Rhinos last Thursday night showed exactly why he has a very strong claim for the scrum half spot for England in the upcoming series against New Zealand.

His only competition comes from Wigan Warriors scrum half and the current incumbent Matty Smith.

Smith is a good player – but that is all he is and I do not think he offers enough with the ball in hand to give us enough opportunities to defeat the no. 1 ranked Kiwis.

Gale does, and the opposition may not know too much about him.

He would be definitely be in my starting XIII but it will be interesting to see what England Head Coach Steve McNamara thinks and to see if he will be influenced by his assistant James Lowes who coached Gale at Bradford Bulls last year.

Wolves Head Coach Tony Smith.

Wolves in disarray??

At the start of the season I tipped Warrington to win the competition.

I felt that the addition of 2014 Man of Steel winner Daryl Clark would give an additional attacking dimension to a team full of speed merchants and try scorers like Joel Monaghan, Ryan Atkins and Stefan Ratchford and that Ashton Sims would further enhance a powerful forward pack including England internationals Chris Hill, Mickey Higham and Ben Westwood.
Add in the expected improvement of Gareth O’Brien’s partnership with Richie Myler and the youth of Ben Harrison and James Laithwaite (I didn’t even mention Ben Currie) and I felt that they at last had the right ingredients to take the Super League crown after being runners up in 2012 and 2013.

How wrong could I have been. The Wolves have never really got going this season.

The same can be said for Clark. He has failed to reach anywhere near the level of performance that he achieved for Castleford last season and I believe he will struggle to keep hold of his international place as a consequence.

But the buck doesn’t just lie with Clark. The Wolves have not settled on a half back partnership all season with either injuries, loss of form or the tinkering of Head Coach Tony Smith meaning that the Wolves have got through numerous pairings that were never able to get an understanding of each other and in turn failed to control the team.

The mid-season loss of hooker Mickey Higham to Leigh Centurions irked Smith and the Wolves and seemed to affect them more than it should have done, although it did bring about the return of young Brad Dwyer from a season long loan spell at London Broncos and he has been a stand out performer in the second half of the season.

Richie Myler never seems to fulfil the potential everyone thinks he has and finally Smith appears to have got tired of waiting to see the best of him on a regular basis and has not offered him a new contract. In addition Smith has this week released another young half back, Gareth O’Brien, along with club captain Joel Monaghan, who still has one year left on his contract, and veteran forward Roy Asotasi.

Monaghan has not had his best season in Wolves colours with ONLY 16 tries (after a hat trick against Catalans this weekend) but at a try per game in over 140 appearances in a very successful 5 year career at the Wolves I think they would fare better next season by pairing Monaghan with new signing Tom Lineham on the wings rather than Gene Ormesby or Kevin Penny – neither of whom have convinced me that they are at Monaghan’s level.

Strangely, Smith has not ruled out a return to Warrington for O’Brien sometime in the future. He seems to want O’Brien to prove himself at another club, looking likely to be Salford Red Devils, before maybe returning as the finished article at a later date. If Smith feels he has the potential to be a top Super League half back, why release him instead of moulding him into the player he wants him to be??

Chris Bridge will also be a big loss, he is a player I rate highly and Widnes have made an excellent signing. He has a lot of experience, is a top quality centre and can also do a very good job at half back.

Australian enigma Chris Sandow signed towards the end of the season after a turbulent end to his career at Parramatta Eels and although his first 4 games have not gone that well I believe that he will be one of the stand out players in Super League in 2016. His half back partnership with veteran Aussie international Kurt Gidley, signed from Newcastle Knights, will be interesting as they will have to gel quickly to make sure the Wolves get off to good start next year.

Ben Currie has had an outstanding 2015 and should earn a call up to the England squad and the signing of Jack Hughes from Wigan, after a successful loan spell at Huddersfield Giants in 2015, gives the Wolves good strength in the back row with James Laithwaite due back from a season ending broken leg suffered in the Challenge Cup quarter final win over Leigh Centurions.

To me the squad looks good but do the Wolves have to look off the field a bit more to see why they have under-performed in the last two regular seasons??

Has Head Coach Tony Smith outstayed his welcome? Has he got his feet too firmly under the table?

Is Richard Agar the right man to be his assistant coach?

Smith generally knows when to move on and obviously feels that he can turn around the Wolves fortunes and get them back to major finals in 2016 and beyond.

I think that another struggling year in 2016 may see the club force a change in the coaching set up.

Disillusioned - Richie Mathers

Disillusioned Mathers quits game

I feel some sympathy for the plight that Richie Mathers finds himself in.

The 6 month ban Mathers recently received from the RFL for a perceived breach of the games betting rules has led to him to announce his retirement from the game with immediate effect.

I can’t say that I have ever been a big Mathers fan as he always seemed prone to make too many errors but you cannot argue with the career that he has had.

He has won a Grand Final and World Club Championship with Leeds Rhinos and two Challenge Cup’s with Warrington Wolves.

In addition to that he had a stint in the NRL with Gold Coast Titans and with Super League clubs Wigan Warriors, Castleford Tigers and Wakefield Trinity Wildcats.

Just as importantly, Mathers seems to be well respected and liked by fellow players as you can see from his Twitter timeline which features tributes from many former team mates.

Mathers has always seemed like a stand up and intelligent guy with thoughts on how to improve the game and his current predicament seems way out of character to me.

The official RFL statement at the time his punishment was decided stated:

London Broncos player Richard Mathers has been suspended from all Rugby League activity for six months after being found guilty of breaching the sport’s rules relating to betting.

An independent tribunal found Mr Mathers guilty of providing inside information on his club’s playing strengths and pre-match preparations, and of encouraging other people to bet on the outcome of a match using the social media messaging application, Whatsapp.

In response, on his own website, Mathers states ‘’I strenuously maintain my innocence of all the issues, no evidence was found against me and I was convicted on the grounds of ‘comfortable satisfaction.’

Now, I am no legal expert and had to look up what ‘comfortable satisfaction’ actually means and the internet gave me this:

‘’The common law has developed many principles in relation to evidence, including two standards of proof, one for criminal cases and one for civil matters. Many sporting disputes are now settled by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and it utilises a third standard of proof, namely 'comfortable satisfaction', which is defined as lying in between the criminal 'beyond reasonable doubt' and the civil 'balance of probabilities'. Despite stating that it is not bound by the rules of evidence, an examination of CAS drug cases indicates that it operates in a similar way to common law courts in regards to how it uses the evidence presented to it.’’

I’m not much clearer on what it means either!!

Also on his website Mathers seems to indicate that identity theft may have played a part in his downfall and he also says that he has been warned against an appeal as the consequences may have been even more dire.

There is no doubt that this is not the way to an end a successful career in any sport and that Mathers and his family will have been under considerable stress in the 6 months between the alleged offence and the final outcome of the investigation.

The fact that the supposed inside information was for a London Broncos match away against the, at the time, rampant Leigh Centurions makes it seem even more unlikely that anyone would need to consider supposed insider information to help them decide on which way to bet on this match – Leigh ended up winning 64-12!!!

My main query on this subject is if Mathers is insisting he is innocent, why does he not release the Whatsapp messages for everyone to see – if he is as innocent as he says surely that would be the route to go down.

I hope this stain on his career and reputation can be washed away eventually and that the rest of Mathers’ life is a success for him and his family – I’m not sure that he has deserved to have his career end like this.

A bit of extra time thinking…..

It seems that Jarryd Haynes success over in America in the NFL has inspired Brisbane Broncos wingman Daniel Vidot to head over and see if he can make his fortune. Does Vidot have a NFL trial lined up?? No, he’s not interested in playing American Football – Vidot is going to have a shot at wresting in the WWE!! The Samoa international has struggled to get a First Grade game under Wayne Bennett at the Broncos in 2015 and has seen moves to other NRL and Super League clubs not materialise, therefore he is flying out to the WWE HQ in Orlando, Florida for a 3 day trial later this month. Are there any Super League stars who could make it in the WWE?

Salford Red Devils have been a Soap Opera all season and at least they have managed to close off one storyline by eventually agreeing a settlement with former Head Coach Iestyn Harris. He can now get off his sick bed and back to work.

The current storyline involves star signing Rangi Chase. Club owner Marwan Koukash has this weekend tweeted that Chase was told he could leave the club, on a free transfer, as far back as June. Chase hasn’t been involved for the Red Devils for the last few weeks and it appears that he will be on the move permanently in the near future, although his recent comments on Instagram were worrying and seemed to indicate some kind of depression issue that, hopefully, his club are taking seriously.

I’ve just about recovered from the Wembley Challenge Cup Final debacle and, fortunately, so have Hull KR and Kieran Dixon. 3 from 3 in the middle 8’s since the Wembley disaster has seen us guarantee our spot in Super League in 2016 and it was great to see Dixon bounce back with two tries in the defeat of Wakefield Trinity Wildcats and another four tries the following week in a convincing win over Bradford Bulls – all of those tries came from the wing rather than full back. I’ll be honest, right at the start of the season I was slightly dismayed that Dixon was given the no. 1 shirt over Ben Cockayne. Dixon has improved immensely in that position this year but has always been prone to errors – it was a good move by coach Chris Chester to keep him in the side but take him out of the firing line after his Final shocker. He is an immensely talented player.

On the negative side at Hull KR I am really disappointed that both Tyrone McCarthy and Kris Welham will be leaving the club. McCarthy has only been at the club for one season but has made a great impact through his attitude and professionalism and was made Captain when Terry Campese suffered a long term injury. A clause in his contract was triggered by the approach of St. George Illawarra Dragons and no-one blames Tyrone for having a shot at the NRL. On the other hand Kris Welham is Rovers longest serving player and scored his 100^th try in the recent win over the Bulls. The rumours started in pre-season that he would be leaving the club and, after a couple of poor seasons, not many people would have been upset.

However, 2015 has seen Welham return to top form and it is only recently that the rumours have started again. Rovers offered him a new contract but it seems that the terms offered are below what he is currently earning and he has received a better offer elsewhere – from Bradford Bulls apparently. It is such a shame as we need to keep hold of our local boys plus my 6 year old is gutted – he and Kris share two things in common – they are both rugby players and both have the same colour hair. Good luck Kris!!!

Kris Welham scores his 100th try

Welham lookalike - my son Kingsley.

 

Finally, obviously scoring all of those tries at Wembley has taken SOMETHING out of the Leeds Rhinos – three straight defeats since the Final has seen them put the potential treble of Challenge Cup, League Leaders Shield and Grand Final winners at risk. And apparently, Brian McDermott is not concerned!!!

 

You can follow me on Twitter @sharpster69

WHEN WEMBLEY DREAMS TURN INTO NIGHTMARES

Sack Chris Chester. Ben Cockayne should have played full back instead of Kieran Dixon. James Green should have been on the bench instead of Dane Tilse or Mitch Allgood. Albert Kelly wasn’t fit. Dane Chisholm should have been on the bench.

These are just some of the things I have read or heard since Hull KR’s Wembley dream became a nightmare on Saturday afternoon against a rampant Leeds Rhinos side.

Certainly sacking Chester is a non-starter and I doubt that any of the other changes suggested, with the benefit of hindsight by our supporters, would have made too much of a difference against a Rhinos team brimming with experience and world class talent and totally on top of it’s game.

In the 4 weeks since the semi-finals the excitement in the east side of Hull had been steadily building. Match tickets, train tickets and merchandise had been bought, coaches and hotel rooms booked, a charity single recorded and the fitness of Albert Kelly had been the main subject of conversation such was his importance to the chance of Rovers winning the Cup for the first time since 1980.

Rover’s fans, many of whom had not been born at the time of our last visit to Wembley in 1986, were dreaming about what it would be like to visit the new Wembley Stadium and upset the odds and beat the Rhinos.

I had a dream that a red and white guardian angel had her arms held tightly around the Challenge Cup this year and had beaten off the black and amber guardian angel of the Bradford Bulls, withheld the might of the arrogant Wigan Warriors cherry and white angel, charged through the red and yellow Gallic angel from Catalans and cut a swathe through the shocked Primrose and Blue angel of the Warrington Wolves – I was hoping that she would be strong enough to withstand the mighty challenge of the guardian angel from Leeds decked out in blue and amber.

I travelled down on Saturday morning on coach with my 4 kids aged 6, 9, 12 and 13 – we all had team shirts (my 9 year old a Hull FC shirt) and we had bought scarves, flags and rosettes as well and my 6 year old boy had learnt the words to ‘A Little Respect’ and was constantly watching the video on YouTube.

Ready for the off!

It was going to be a long day – up before 6 a.m. for the coach to leave at 7a.m. and back home probably around midnight.

It would also be a day full of chat, friends, laughter, hope, heartache, emotion, pain, desperation, disappointment, inspiration, excitement and tiredness.

My 9 year old Hull FC supporting son (I still struggle with this) was the only non-Hull KR fan on our coach and was the subject of some gentle banter throughout the smooth and uneventful coach journey down to London.

We went into a bar near Wembley Stadium with a mixture of Rovers and Leeds Rhinos fans stood outside and a big guy in a Rovers training shirt came up to my son asking him what he was doing there in a Hull FC shirt – now Lleyton is a shy lad when he is in new company and was unsure how to respond. The Rovers fan took him by the hand and led him over to the Rovers fans that he was with. As Lleyton was looking back at me wondering what was going on the guy then slowly pulled off his Rovers shirt to reveal a Hull FC vest. He then put his arm around Lleyton’s shoulder and said ‘’you’re not alone son’’ and started singing ‘’Old Faithful’’ at the top of his voice with Lleyton joining in and laughing nervously alongside him. He was wearing the Rovers shirt because he had lost a bet.


Legends Statue

Although we just missed the unveiling it was awe-inspiring to view the new legends of rugby league sculpture that is located on the Wembley Stadium concourse. Saturday was exactly 120 years since the birth of the Greatest Game in the George Hotel in Huddersfield and Rugby League should be very proud that it is only the second sport, after football with the Bobby Moore statue, to have a permanent presence at the National Stadium.

The five iconic figures on the one ton bronze statue, wonderfully created by East Yorkshire sculptor Stephen Winterburn, are Gus Risman, Eric Ashton, Billy Boston MBE, Alex Murphy OBE and Martin Offiah MBE. These are true legends of the game – if some of you young one’s who happen to read this don’t know who they are then check out YouTube – you will find some fantastic footage and some Rugby League brilliance.

You can also watch a short film about the sculpture here: youtu.be/dCX-PBh0zFo      

Me and Stevo

The statue really is a fitting tribute to our sport and is worth a visit to the stadium alone. The three legends still with us – Boston, Murphy and Offiah – were all present along with Eric Ashton’s wife and Gus Risman’s son, Bev. Offiah in particular looked very snazzy and I managed to snaffle a photo with Stevo who had managed to get himself on the guest list.

Wembley Stadium

Me and the kids entered the stadium and took in the fantastic view after we had got our breath back after climbing to virtually the top of the stadium (my fault for purchasing the cheapest tickets!!) and were in time to watch the very impressive Ysgol Gyfun Gymraeg Glantaf school from South Wales defeat Wade Deacon school from Widnes 40-6 to win the Year 7 Champion Schools Final and take home the Steven Mullaney Memorial Trophy – they really did play some excellent rugby league and showed that Malet Lambert School from my home town from Hull were not far away from being the top school team in the country. Glantaf visited Hull in the quarter finals and trailed 10-6 to Malet Lambert before a very late converted try won them the game 12-10.

The kids.

As I mentioned earlier we were seated right at the top of the stadium and I can see how the height could be an issue with some people. We were sat enjoying the schools match when some elderly ladies approached us to get past to their seats – they were very nervous because of the height and would only shuffle past us with their backs to the stadium and holding onto each one of us as they passed – semi-rigid with fear. I must admit I could not stop laughing and I was in hysterics when they realised, after they had nervously got past us, that they were heading in the wrong direction and needed to get past us again to get to their seats – cue a repeat of the shuffling and the holding on and the apologising before they safely found their way to the right seats. My daughter chastised me for laughing so much but I just couldn’t help it.

At this time we were still really looking forward to the match and had a strong belief that our boys could bring the Challenge Cup home. The players came out to a huge cheer as they warmed up and we had already seen on social media that Albert Kelly was fit and that Kieran Dixon would start at full back – the surprise was that local lad James Green, after a monumental semi-final performance, had been discarded in preference to the recently returned Mitch Allgood – not a game changer as far as I am concerned but I thought Green deserved a place on the bench.

Both sets of supporters were in really good voice and the Rovers fans gave a great rendition of Erasure’s ‘A Little Respect’ which has been adopted by the club since the semi-final.

The real emotion of the day was saved for ‘Abide With Me’ which was sang beautifully and brilliantly by Lizzie Jones, the widow of Keighley Cougars Danny who so tragically died at a match earlier this year. I knew this would be emotional and I knew that she would receive a huge and wonderful reception from everyone in the stadium and there were one or two tears rolling down my cheeks as she sang – but what really set me off was the photograph on the big screens of her and Danny looking at each other with their children – such a beautiful photograph and such a sad time – those few minutes will stay with me for a long time and I am really honoured that I was there to see her perform and very proud to say that she is part of the Rugby League family – she has done her husband and family proud.

Fetch the tissues and watch Lizzie’s brilliant performance again here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpQQW9WQDvE

As Lizzie left the field the two teams entered and it was fantastic to see my team walk onto the Wembley pitch. I was excited to have my children with me to see this, they don’t realise where this club of ours has come from in the last 10 years and only know Super League – they don’t know about the 12 years outside of the top flight, the National Leagues, the heartache of playing at home in front of 1100 fans when you had been used to seeing the club play in major finals at the old Wembley Stadium, Elland Road, Headingley or Boothferry Park in front of thousands, playing in the third tier of the sport, going into administration and wondering if we would have a club left to support.

Kids are all about the here and now and to have them there with me was brilliant and I hope it is not the last time they get to see their team at Wembley. I knew how tough this game would be but I was hoping that the guardian angel I mentioned earlier was going to be on her game. As everyone knows it was not to be – this article is not a match report so I’m not going to go into the where’s and why fore’s and who scored how many tries and who made the most errors.

When you get beaten 50-0 you can’t have any complaints – the harsh fact is that we were nowhere near good enough and were blown away by as good a team performance as I have seen in a long time.

Leeds Rhinos shut us down completely and there defensive performance was even more impressive than the wonderful tries that they scored – believe me this Hull KR side can score tries and it has some dangerous attacking players – but they could not make the slightest dent in the Leeds Rhinos armour. The forwards in particular could not break the iron grip that enveloped them every time they took the ball up.

Ironically, Kieran Dixon was our main attacking threat and probably tried to do too much himself at times as he attempted to make up for the errors that cost us so much on the day – I hope he has the support of all at the club because he is a massive talent.  

The first 20 minutes of the first half showed what a tough job we had on our hands. Rovers could not get out of their own half to gain decent field position and were constantly either having to defend or take the ball out from within 10 yards of their line – the Rhinos were also cleverly attacking the short side which caused constant problems.

16-0 down after 20 minutes was not good but the boys showed some spirit in the second quarter to keep Leeds out for the rest of the half.

It was clear that we would have to score first in the second half but Tom Briscoe’s break away try from an attacking kick just broke our hearts and it was clear that the rest of the half would be about keeping the score down and trying to get across the line ourselves – we certainly wouldn’t be taking the Cup back to East Hull.

As everyone knows, we didn’t keep the score down and didn’t manage to get across the whitewash and I sank deeper and deeper into my seat as the half went on – particularly in the last 10 minutes when the Rhinos cut loose and scored three converted tries.

After the score got to 44-0 I said to my eldest boy that we HAD to keep the score below 50 – in the same breath Briscoe scored his record 5th try and Sinfield converted to get make the score 50-0. It wasn’t really until that final 10 minutes that we had a couple of real opportunities to score ourselves but we bombed them – it was the story of our day.

Now when your team gets beaten by 50 points you are usually pretty angry with your players but I had to stay right to the end and see the boys come over to us because I know that they will be just as gutted as us supporters – if not more so.

They certainly didn’t wake up on Saturday morning with the intention of getting hammered and to be fair they put in a huge amount of effort and determination but it just wasn’t enough – the team didn’t play well enough and the players just weren’t good enough – the difference in class was quite embarrassing at times but Leeds can do that to anyone on their day – it just happened that they did it to my team on our biggest day for 29 years.

As we left the stadium there was no ballyhoo or particular excitement from the Leeds fans – they have seen it all before and it was probably a little bit too boring and predictable for them and I guess they would have welcomed a real battle to win the Cup rather than just be handed it on a plate.

The coach journey home to Hull was subdued and tiring and we eventually got home around 1130pm – I had to have a couple of glasses of wine to help cheer me up and put me to sleep.

I had a lie in on Sunday morning and managed to resist watching the match on TV when I eventually dragged myself out of bed – I really don’t think I will be able to do that ever. We decided to go to Pizza Hut later in the afternoon and would you believe it that on the table right behind us was a family of Leeds Rhinos fans!!!!

That just summed up my weekend really.