Following on from my highly critical article after the
embarrassing 28-0 Derby defeat http://www.seriousaboutrl.com/5/archives/08-2014/1.html
at the end of last August, as we are on the cusp of a new Super League season,
and on the back of comeback win in the pre-season trial at the KC Stadium last
Sunday, now is a good time to evaluate the changes that Hull Kingston Rovers
have made to their squad and backroom staff in an attempt to improve on a
highly disappointing 2014 and ensure that, at the least, Hull KR finish in one
of the all important top 8 positions
after 23 rounds this year.
Prior to the 2014 season, Chairman Neil Hudgell stated that
Hull KR had their strongest squad in the Super League era and would look to
build on an 8th place finish in 2013.
12 months down the line and 13 new players have joined the
club with a similar number leaving.
Three of last year’s major signing’s, Grand Final winning scrum
half Kris Keating, former New South Wales prop Justin Poore and former
Queensland forward and current Papua New Guinea international Neville Costigan
have all left the club.
Poore was unfortunate that the injury he received on Easter
Monday at Catalans Dragons, a broken kneecap, has ended his career. He never
really got going at Rovers as two early season suspensions restricted his
appearances prior to the Easter Weekend.
Keating never hit the heights that was expected of him, came
nowhere taking over the mantle of skipper Michael Dobson and never settled in
the UK. It was clear that new coach Chris Chester was not keen to keep him at
the club and a deal was agreed to release him from his contract to allow him to
return home to Australia and join St. George Illawarra.
Costigan is the most disappointing loss of the three. After
a slow opening to his time at Hull KR, he put in a number of strong
performances in the Rovers pack and was expected to be a major part of the
forward pack in 2015.
His decision to remain in Australia and have the second year
of his contract cancelled just prior to the start of pre-season training was
disappointing and un-professional.
Even greater losses though are those of our joint captains
from last season – Travis Burns and Josh Hodgson.
Josh Hodgson - NRL bound. |
Travis Burns |
Burns ran the show for Rovers last year and excelled – his
half back partnership with his former Penrith Panthers colleague Luke Walsh at
St. Helens could determine whether they retain the Super League crown or not.
Other first team regulars to leave the KC Lightstream
Stadium are Craig Hall, whose versatility and skill is a big loss in my eyes,
he has joined Wakefield Trinity Wildcats with a view to playing regular Super
League rugby, wingman Omari Caro and forward Jamie Langley did not have their
contract’s renewed, full back Greg Eden has joined the Brisbane Broncos, Rhys
Lovegrove has re-located to London and joined the Broncos of the capital in the
Championship, whilst David Hodgson, Jason Netherton and Sean Gleeson have all
retired.
Hodgson and Burns are big boots to fill – they were the
dominant players in a struggling team in 2014 and with Keating also leaving it
means that a brand new half back partnership will be steering the Robins ship
around in 2015.
That new half back partnership looks likely to be Terry
Campese, already appointed as club captain, and Albert Kelly.
Albert Kelly - exciting. |
I expect Campese, signed from Canberra Raiders where he had
a difficult last couple of years, to be the general and direct the play with
Kelly, signed from Gold Coast Titans and not yet 24 years of age, being the more dynamic and off the cuff half
back and I think he has the potential to be one of the most exciting half backs
in the competition.
Terry Campese - new club captain. |
One of the many things the Rovers backline lacked last year
was speed – that shouldn’t be the case in 2015.
We have mentioned Kelly already, he has bags of speed and
Rovers have raided the London Broncos for another young back in Kieran Dixon. Dixon was out injured due to a badly damaged knee for a full 12 months up to the end of last season.
At the time of his injury in 2013 he was in the England Knights squad and was rated very highly – probably higher than Mason Caton-Brown who has since signed for Salford Red Devils and looks a likely England player of the future.
Kieran Dixon |
In the first two pre-season friendly’s Dixon has started at
full back and excelled, scoring an outstanding try in last week’s win at the KC
Stadium as well as kicking three
conversions from the touchline.
Dixon will face competition for the full back berth from Ben
Cockayne who was outstanding in that position last year until injury ruined his
season. Cockayne has had close season surgery and will have a hell of a fight
to regain his favoured position.
Although more under the radar than Campese and Kelly, I
expect ex Parramatta flyer Ken Sio to be one of the signing’s of the year in
the whole of Super League,
At 25 years of age, Sio is in the prime of his career and is
the type of player that will set Super League alight – he scored 13 tries in
just 12 NRL appearances for the Eels in 2014 and has a career record of 37
tries in 57 appearances.
On the opposite side of the field could line up Italian international Josh Mantellato.
Not a lot is known about Mantellato in the UK – he is best
known for kicking the drop goal that secured Italy a historic 15-14 victory
over England in the lead up to the 2013 World Cup.
He has little NRL experience, having made only 2 first grade
appearances for the Newcastle Knights, yet he is a prolific points scorer in
the reserve grade New South Wales Cup and has been named on the wing in the
team of the year for the last 3 years.
It will be interesting to see if that form translates well
to the Super League.
Darrell Goulding |
Maurice Blair, a team mate of Kelly’s at the Gold Coast
Titans, has also signed but I am not sure where he will fit in at the moment.
When he signed it was presumed that he would form a half
back partnership with Kelly – but then Campese was recruited and you can
guarantee now that Campese and Kelly will be the half back pairing for as long
as they stay fit.
This means Blair will be a back up or will be moved to the
centre where he has experience as well.
Centre is a hotly contested position – Goulding will definitely
have one side tied up – and I would like to see young Salter handed the other
centre position.
Throw in the experienced Kris Welham, who had a nightmare
2014 including being loaned out to dual registration club Gateshead Thunder on
a couple of occasions, Graeame Horne, who is more of a back rower these days,
Mantellato who can also play centre and the youngster Macauley Hallet, who made
a try scoring debut at the end of 2014, and you can see it’s going to be tough
for whoever is left out.
The pack actually looks stronger all round than last year but we
will do well to cover the loss of Hodgson at hooker.
Keal Carlile will take over the hooking duties backed up by
the unknown Frenchman John Boudebza who was signed from Lezignan.
Keal Carlile - big opportunity. |
Mick Weyman had a great first season in Super League scoring
7 tries and being a very popular player with the supporters who loved the
effort and desire he showed every week.
The front row has been strengthened greatly by the arrival
of Mitch Allgood from Parramatta and the surprise signing of Ryan Bailey from
Leeds Rhinos.No-one saw the Bailey signing coming as everyone assumed that he would stay at Leeds for life – but he has come to Rovers for a new challenge and more game time and I expect to see a more mature and disciplined Bailey line up alongside Weyman.
Youngsters Adam Walker and James Green will, hopefully,
continue the improvement they have shown over the last 12 months.
If they do, we have a strong front row rotation and the back
row also looks stronger.Kevin Larroyer - outstanding in 2014. |
French international Kevin Larroyer was outstanding last
year and if he continues that fine form he will be a certain starter – add in
the fact he is comfortable playing 80 minutes and he is a great option to have.
Graeme Horne had a solid 2014 and local youngsters Jordan
Cox, who was courted by St. Helens before agreeing a contract extension, and
Aaron Ollett both had impressive years.
Another young local, Sonny Esslemont also made his first
team debut in 2014 and big things are expected of him.
The back row has been strengthened by the addition of James
Donaldson from Bradford Bulls, the experienced former Warrington Wolves Challenge Cup Final winner Tyrone McCarthy who was signed
from Northern Pride in Australia and Wigan back rower Greg Burke has joined on a 12 month
loan deal.
There is certainly more strength in depth and the
recruitment seems solid and, in places, inspired.
But the biggest signing could have come off the pitch.Willie Poching - winning experience. |
Willie Poching has joined as assistant coach and his
experience in winning cultures at Leeds Rhinos and Warrington Wolves over the
last few years could prove the difference between a struggle to make the 8 or competing
for a top six place.
Despite the poor end to last season under Chester, he does
seem to have recruited well and there is a feel good factor floating around at
the moment – especially after coming back from 22-6 down to beat Hull FC 28-22
at the KC stadium last Sunday.
Drawing 6-6 at half time the optimism was still there – 40
minutes later and the Rhinos had scored 28 unanswered points and won the game
easily – we cannot have that repeated if the team, and Chester, are to be taken
seriously.
The number of second half collapses under Chester last year
was frightening and that has to have been resolved if we are to be competitive
this year.
Hopefully, if everyone stays fit I think we will make the 8
and challenge for 7th or maybe 6th – no higher than 6th –
but I must admit I will be happy to avoid the middle 8 play offs and secure our Super League position for another year.
Having said that, we saw what happened at Castleford last season – who says
this can’t be the year of the Robin – it’ll be about time. ==================================
Albert Kelly in action - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CI1Kl0XdkOU
Ken Sio in action - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54czfT_nWHs
Josh Mantellato in action - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3A3LD-Uq14g